How I judge
I only call a service European when it passes all three of my checks. Passes some? Then I say “partly European”.
Every page shows my sources and the date I last checked.
My three checks
- ✓Check 1
A European company
Based and owned in the EU, the EEA or Switzerland. A European office of a US company doesn't count.
- ✓Check 2
Your data stays in Europe
Your emails, photos and files are stored on servers in Europe.
- ✓Check 3
Outside US law
No US parent company or US cloud that could be forced to hand over your data.
The labels you'll see
- European
- Passes all three checks. For example Proton Mail or Vivaldi.
- Partly European
- A European company that fails one check, like Ecosia, whose results come partly from Bing.
- Not Big Tech
- Not European, but not Big Tech either, and not funded by ads. Like Signal. Always shown last.
By US Big Tech I mean the few US companies that hold most people's digital life: Google (Alphabet), Apple, Microsoft, Amazon and Meta, and AI companies such as OpenAI.
How I choose my pick
- 1Easiest switch
Can you start without technical knowledge? Is there a tool that brings your data along?
- 2Honest about cost
Is there a free plan? What does it cost, and what do you lose?
- 3Clear about how it makes money
Subscriptions, ads that don't follow you, or donations: I tell you which. If an app is free, you should know what pays for it. I prefer apps that don't make money from a profile of you.
When no option passes all three checks, I pick the most European one that works well, and say so on the page. That's why Ecosia and Mastodon are my picks, while they're labelled “partly European”. My pick is my own judgment based on these points; there's no score behind it. Prefer something else? The other good options are always right below it.
How I check facts
- ✓The provider's own pages first
Prices, help pages and privacy policies. Every page lists them.
- ✓A date on every page
I check prices and features against the providers' own pages, and update the date when I do.
- ✓“Tested” only when it's true
A guide only says “Tested on a real device” after we've followed it ourselves. Until then it says which official help pages it was checked against.
Questions people ask
Why is a Swiss or Norwegian service European?
Switzerland and Norway aren't in the EU, but they are in Europe and have privacy laws comparable to the GDPR. What matters to me is that a service isn't owned by, or dependent on, a US company that US law can reach.
Why are Ecosia and Qwant only partly European?
Both are European companies, but part of their search results still comes from Microsoft's Bing. Together they are building their own European index. It already answers most searches in France and is now being rolled out in Germany. When that covers the rest of Europe, I'll change the label.
Why do you mention Signal?
Because many people ask about it. Signal is a US non-profit, so it doesn't pass my checks, but it isn't Big Tech, isn't funded by ads and can't read your messages. I show options like this last, labelled 'Not Big Tech', never as my pick.
Do companies pay to be listed?
No. No company has paid to be listed on Local Frank or to be chosen as my pick.
I found a mistake. What now?
Please tell me at info@hertge.com. Prices and features change, and I'd rather hear it from you than keep something wrong online. I check it, correct it and update the 'last checked' date.